Bill Dance and Jerry McKinnis finished only 3 ounces behind the winners in an event that was held at a 100-acre private fishery located 40 miles northeast of Montgomery.
In the spirit of the smack-talking that went on all day among this group of longtime friends, McKinnis accepted the results under protest.
“We were so much better anglers than them, I assumed we were going to win,” said McKinnis, who is now a part-owner of B.A.S.S. “Bill and I are going to go study the tapes, analyze all that and make sure this is all on the up and up, then I’ll be glad to comment.”
McKinnis, 75, who hosted The Fishing Hole on ESPN for more than 25 years, and Dance, 69, who still hosts his show Bill Dance Outdoors, might not ever have had more fun than they did in the 4 1/2 hours of competition today.
“If we do it again next year, which I really want to do, we will have more teams and really make it a blow-out deal,” McKinnis said. “This was just a spur of the moment thing. We said, ‘Let’s go have some fun.’ And we darned sure did that.”
They caught plenty of bass on the way to doing it. Eaker, who is from Cherryville, N.C., and Cook, who now manages his hunting ranch near Lawton, Okla., caught a five-bass limit that weighed 19 pounds, 3 ounces. Clunn from Ava, Mo., and Martin of Hemphill, Texas, finished second with 19-0. McKinnis, who lives in Little Rock, and Dance, who is from Collierville, Tenn., took third with 19-0. Bobby Murray of Hot Springs, Ark., and Guido Hibdon from Sunshine Beach, Mo., finished fourth with 9-11.
Those big names in B.A.S.S. history own nine Bassmaster Classic trophies, six Bassmaster Angler of the Year titles, 40 Bassmaster wins and 312 top-10 finishes.
Eaker, 71, fished the Elite Series through 2010, won more than $600,000 in B.A.S.S. events and qualified for 10 Classics. He ranked Sunday’s tournament as one of this top-five fishing memories of all time.
“We really had a great time,” Eaker said. “We caught most of our weight in the first hour-and-a-half. But we did cull some fish after that. And we were culling by ounces. If I hadn’t weighed the fish on a scale, we might have thrown the tournament away.”
As the four teams were leaving the dock at 9 a.m. Sunday, Dance landed a 5-3 largemouth. It came at 9:04 a.m., and it was fitting because Dance caught the first-ever bass in a B.A.S.S. tournament. In 1967, founder Ray Scott held his first tournament on Arkansas’ Beaver Lake. Dance had borrowed a boat that had a 60-hp motor on it. He raced out ahead of the field, stopped while the others were still leaving the takeoff area and caught a fish on his first cast.
Dance and McKinnis figured their chief competition would come from Clunn, 65, the four-time Classic champion, and Martin, 70, who had been catching fish from one area of the lake all morning long.
“Rick figured out a pattern in about 15 minutes, and we just blistered them,” said Martin, who qualified for 19 Classics and won it in 1974.
LEGENDS STANDINGS- ALL-STAR CHAMPIONSHIP
2011 Legends Fishing Event 7/31/11
Private Lake, AL
Standings
Team No./lbs-oz
Guy Eaker/Ken Cook 19-03
Rick Clunn/Tommy Martin 19-01
Bill Dance/Jerry McKinnis 19-00
Guido Hibdon/Bobby Murray 09-11